Searching for an engagement ring in Toronto offers a thrilling opportunity. The city boasts a vibrant jewellery scene with diverse options, including quaint local boutiques and renowned retailers, all tailored to suit your style and budget.
This guide provides expert insights on the best places to purchase engagement rings in Toronto. It also offers practical tips for selecting the perfect ring and highlights top locations for trying on designs.
Why Toronto’s the Place for Engagement Rings
Toronto’s jewellery scene excels with exceptional craftsmanship and variety. Talented jewellers, ethical sourcing, and decades of expertise define the city’s offerings.
Options range from GIA-certified diamonds to sustainable lab-grown gemstones, ensuring every preference is met. Toronto’s jewellers prioritize personalization, creating rings that reflect your unique love story.
Visiting boutiques in The Junction or downtown studios guarantees a memorable and tailored experience.
Top Spots to Buy Engagement Rings in Toronto
Here’s my roundup of the best places to shop for engagement rings in Toronto. Each one has its flair, from custom designs to wallet-friendly options.
1. Solitaire Jewellery
Nestled in the heart of Toronto, Solitaire Jewellery (Solitaire x Alex Armen) is a haven for couples seeking bespoke engagement rings that capture their unique story. Since 1983, Solitaire has been crafting custom jewellery with a focus on artistry and elegance. Led by artist and designer Alex Armen, their team combines traditional craftsmanship with cutting-edge techniques, such as 3D printing, to bring your vision to life.
From ethically sourced GIA-graded natural diamonds to vibrant gemstones cut in Germany’s Idar-Oberstein, Solitaire ensures every piece is a masterpiece. Whether you’re dreaming of a classic solitaire, a vintage-inspired design, or a modern halo ring, their personalized process—starting with a one-on-one consultation—makes the experience unforgettable. Plus, their commitment to quality and authenticity shines through in every handcrafted piece.
Why Go With Solitaire Jewellery?
- Unmatched personalization with artist Alex Armen
- Ethically sourced diamonds and gemstones
- 40+ years of crafting Toronto’s finest custom rings
2. Randor Jewellery
Right in the heart of downtown, Randor Jewellery is a favourite for GIA-certified diamonds and custom rings. Randy and his crew explain diamonds and metals in a way that clicks, even if you’re new to this.
Shoppers love their honest prices and chill vibe. Drop by their showroom to try on rings or discuss a one-of-a-kind design.
Why Go With Randor?
- Pros at GIA-certified diamonds
- Fair prices that beat chain stores
- Personal chats for custom creations
3. Serli & Siroan
Serli & Siroan has been in operation for over 45 years, making it Toronto’s largest independent jewellery store. They’ve got a whopping 17,000+ GIA and GL-certified diamonds.
Their rings are handmade on-site, and they offer tons of ways to customize. People can’t get enough of the family-run feel and payment plans that work for you.
Why Go With Serli & Siroan?
- Massive diamond and gemstone lineup
- In-house artisans for unique rings
- Flexible financing options
4. Kimberfire
Kimberfire blends tech and heart for a smooth shopping experience. Based in Toronto, they offer virtual or in-person meetups. Their wholesale diamond connections ensure you receive great prices without compromising on quality. Natural or lab-grown diamonds? They’ve got both.
Why Go With Kimberfire?
- Online or in-person consultations
- Wholesale diamonds for better deals
- Gorgeous, high-quality craftsmanship
5. Livia Diamonds
Livia Diamonds is your spot for custom rings that stand out. They use lab-grown or mined diamonds, as well as Moissanite, all of which are crafted in Canada. Their team helps you nail every detail of your design.
Even better, a portion of every purchase supports SickKids Hospital, so your ring makes a meaningful difference.
Why Go With Livia Diamonds?
- Ethical stones with custom options
- Gives back to a great cause
- Easy virtual or in-person visits
6. Cullen Jewellery
Cullen Jewellery is all about sustainable lab-grown diamonds and Moissanite. Their online ring builder lets you mix and match settings and stones, with delivery straight to Toronto.
Want to see the goods? Book a showroom visit. Fans love their green approach and stunning designs.
Why Go With Cullen Jewellery?
- Eco-friendly diamonds and Moissanite
- Super user-friendly online tool
- Top-notch customer service
7. Alexis Gallery
Alexis Gallery is a gem for custom rings, offering diamonds, lab-grown stones, or cool gems like sapphires or morganite. Their low overhead keeps prices affordable without cutting corners. Shoppers rave about their friendly, no-BS approach.
Why Go With Alexis Gallery?
- Unique gemstone options
- Budget-friendly quality
- Awesome, transparent service
8. Penwarden Fine Jewellery
Tucked away on Mount Pleasant, Penwarden Fine Jewellery feels like a hidden treasure. No appointment needed—just walk in and browse their handcrafted rings.
Their lotus bezel setting is a fan favourite. They’re also pros at turning heirloom stones into modern pieces.
Why Go With Penwarden?
- Walk-in try-on sessions
- Great for reworking heirloom gems
- Laid-back, friendly vibe
9. Engage Studio
Engage Studio makes ring shopping a blast. Their Toronto showroom has open displays with hundreds of styles to try. Their stone workshop lets you compare diamonds and gems up close.
They offer lab-grown, mined diamonds, or Moissanite, with options available in both virtual and in-person settings.
Why Go With Engage Studio?
- Fun, hands-on try-on experience
- Compare the stones side-by-side
- Designs that fit your wallet
Diamond Buying Tips to Get It Right
Selecting an engagement ring requires some expertise. Here’s my advice for buying a diamond:
- aster the 4Cs: Cut, Colour, Clarity, and Carat are everything. Cut makes the diamond shine, so aim for an excellent or ideal cut. Colour and clarity affect looks—G-H colour and VS2-SI1 clarity give you bang for your buck. Carat is a unit of measurement, but a 0.97-carat stone can save you money over a 1.00-carat stone.
- Go Certified: Always pick GIA-certified diamonds for guaranteed quality. Skip stones without certification.
- Consider Lab-Grown or Moissanite: Lab-grown diamonds are 30% bigger for the same price as mined ones. Moissanite sparkles more and costs less.
- Stick to a Budget: Spend within your means. Ditch the “three months’ salary” myth—focus on a ring that means something.
- Know Her Vibe: Check out her jewellery or ask friends for clues. This ensures the ring matches her style.
- Try Custom: Many Toronto shops offer the option to design your ring. Bring your ideas for something you.
- Shop Local: Small jewellers often outdo big stores in terms of price and service. Chain stores jack up prices.
Jewellery Shopping Tips for an Easy Experience
Jewellery shopping in Toronto can feel big, but these tips keep it simple:
- Start Online: Browse shop websites for inspiration. Look for 360-degree ring videos or close-up pics.
- Plan Ahead: Custom rings take 4-6 weeks, so don’t rush.
- Shop Around: Local jewellers often offer better prices than chain stores. Grab a few quotes.
- Check the Fine Print: Look for free resizing, returns, or warranties. Some spots, like Diamonds Factory, offer a 30-day free resizing policy.
- Trust Reviews: Check Google or Reddit for genuine customer stories.
Wrapping It Up
Selecting the ideal engagement ring in Toronto combines style, quality, and emotional resonance. Solitaire Jewellery excels with bespoke craftsmanship and ethical sourcing, while Penwarden offers a welcoming walk-in experience, ensuring a jeweller for every couple’s story.
Ready to start your journey? Book a consultation with Solitaire Jewellery or one of these top Toronto jewellers to craft a ring that’s as unique as your love.
FAQs About Engagement Rings in Toronto
How much is an engagement ring in Toronto?
It depends on the diamond and style. A solid 1-carat ring from a local shop typically costs between $5,000 and $15,000 CAD. Lab-grown diamonds are cheaper.
Are lab-grown diamonds a smart pick?
They’re eco-friendly, cost less, and shine just as bright. Places like Cullen Jewellery specialize in them.
How do I choose a diamond?
Focus on the 4Cs: Cut, Colour, Clarity, Carat. Select an excellent cut for sparkle and opt for GIA-certified stones.
Can I make a custom ring in Toronto?
Shops like Livia Diamonds, Serli & Siroan, and Alexis Gallery help you design a ring that’s all you.
Where can I try on rings in Toronto?
Check out Penwarden Fine Jewellery, Engage Studio, or Made You Look for hands-on try-on sessions with a wide range of options.
